Students and police clash as France struggles to quell school protests |  Reuters

School blockades, teacher strikes, violent student unrest, riot police: it’s safe to say that the frustrations of France’s populace have been put front and center in the news this week. Hundreds of schools across l’Hexagone have closed, and protesters cite crumbling infrastructure (including falling ceilings, leaking water, broken windows, and rat infestations), overcrowded classrooms (with reports of up to 35 students per class), and staff shortages.

But the students in France may not know exactly what they are up against: the bond market… As yields skyrocket in France (and in many other countries), the government’s cost of borrowing keeps growing, and the looming interest bill rises with it. As a larger share of government spending goes to paying bondholders, that money has to come out of something. History suggests that what it comes out of matters far more than how much, and that the people it comes out of tend to end up in the street.

The oldest tale in French finance

France has been here before. By 1788, the royal budget had to commit half of its total estimated revenue to interest payments on debts already contracted. Two years earlier, bankers had refused to make new advances to the crown, convinced of government mismanagement. In their study of the period, the economists Thomas Sargent and François Velde describe what ensued: unable to raise taxes fast enough to service the debt, and unwilling to default again, Louis XVI convened the Estates General to push reform through. Then came the revolution, and then the guillotine.

Guillotine | Facts, Inventor, & History | Britannica

Two centuries later, James Carville, then advising Bill Clinton, gave the modern version of the lesson after watching bond traders veto the new administration’s spending plans. He said he used to want to be reincarnated as the president or the pope, and now wanted to come back as the bond market, because the bond market can intimidate everybody (and anybody).

The most rigorous evidence on this comes from Jacopo Ponticelli of Northwestern and Hans-Joachim Voth of the University of Zurich, who built a dataset of government revenue and spending for 24 European countries from 1919 to 2008 and matched it against records of riots, demonstrations, general strikes, assassinations and attempted revolutions. They found a clear positive correlation between fiscal retrenchment and instability.

What matters most for France is the composition of those cuts: expenditure cuts were particularly potent in fueling protests, while tax rises had only small and insignificant effects.

They also tested the obvious objection, that recessions cause both budget cuts and unrest, using an IMF dataset of spending shocks unrelated to the business cycle, and found that recessions were not what drove the result. Moderate cuts produced no measurable increase in unrest, but large ones did.

The likely reason spending cuts are so much more combustible than tax increases is that cuts are visible and concentrated. A tax rise is spread across millions of people in small amounts. A wage freeze lands on teachers. A hiring freeze lands on the classroom that now has 35 students in it. It’s clear who’s paying.

France, 2026

French borrowing costs have been climbing all year, and the past two weeks turned that into a rout. On October 2nd the French 10-year yield traded at 4.914%, 139 basis points higher than twelve months earlier. The day before, the gap between French and German 10-year yields widened past 130 basis points, the largest since the eurozone debt crisis of 2012. For context, between 2022 and June 2024 that spread hovered around 40 to 50 basis points. France now pays more than Italy to borrow for a decade: on October 2nd, French ten-year debt yielded 4.90% against Italy’s 4.69%. And on Wednesday the selling resumed, with the 10-year yield jumping 16 basis points in a day and sitting more than 100 basis points above where it started the year.

The budget presented last Thursday is the government’s answer. Finance Minister Roland Lescure said it targets a fiscal adjustment of €54 billion, partly by freezing wages for public sector workers like teachers. Education spending rises 1.7%, below inflation, to €65.53 billion. Education is traditionally the largest item in the French budget, and next year debt servicing is expected to overtake it at €74.5 billion. The country remains under the EU’s excessive deficit procedure.

Teacher unions including Unsa, the CFDT and the CGT joined the student movement on Tuesday, with demands for smaller classes, building renovations and changes to the university admissions system. Student unions called that national day of action despite more than 1,000 arrests and over 100 injuries among pupils and police. In the Paris suburb of Pantin, a fifteen-year-old named Kesia described classes of 35 with not enough chairs and a lunch hour too short for everyone to eat.

One of Ponticelli and Voth’s findings is the reason France is in such a difficult position: austerity episodes that produce unrest tend to be followed by quick reversals of fiscal policy. In other words, governments usually back down.

France doesn’t get such an easy way out. If the government holds the line, the protests continue into an election year. If it reverses, the bond market reprices French debt again, and every additional basis point flows straight into the interest bill that has already pushed past education. One strategist told CNBC this week that the OAT sell-off does not look exhausted. Budget negotiations in a divided National Assembly begin next week.

In 1788 the creditors stopped lending. Today they are still lending, at a higher price every week, and the cost is being passed down the budget until it reaches a classroom in Pantin. I doubt the students protesting will ever read a French bond prospectus in their lives, and yet they are the ones being asked to pay the coupon.

That’ll be all for today, folks.

See ya, and stay curious!

—J&E