Pakistani premier signs Islamabad MoU as mediator between US, Iran

Just to briefly summarize the status of affairs in the Middle East, I will provide some highlights and timestamps as of June 20th, Saturday at 1:30 PM EST. Things are indeed so rapidly in flux that it is necessary to timestamp writing down to the hour-mark. This is to say, all variables, factors, and states of play will likely change by the time you start reading this, or by the time you come around to finishing it.

For that reason, I will not spend too much time on a chronology or digest of the affairs; instead, I will explore some underlying concepts that provide a valuable lens for the current moment, but will also help you analyze both historical and future conflict in a novel and valuable way.

Additionally, before I dive in, it is important to acknowledge our predispositions whenever we write or talk about affairs in the Middle East. I’m not from the Middle East, nor do I have family living there; I have no college degree or work experience in global affairs. I am simply a well-informed student of geopolitical history and, one could say, pompous enough to believe I am the right person to stick my head out of the sand and start talking about the issue. Take everything with a grain of salt where there is no clear fact underlying the statement and take my word that I intend to practice absolute authorial integrity and levelheadedness when dealing in ambiguities.

The Situation

On Wednesday, June 17th, the United States and Iran signed the “Islamabad Memorandum of Understanding,” committing to terminate military operations and lift blockades on Iranian ports. On Thursday, June 18th, Iran “proclaimed” the MoU, thus opening the Strait of Hormuz to marine traffic. Pakistan had taken part in the finalization of the MoU on the 17th, serving as the mediator party. Pakistani Prime Minister Shehbaz Sharif announced technical talks about nuclear containment and details of the agreement in Switzerland on Friday, June 19th but then refused to bring an Iranian attache because they needed fighting in Lebanon to stop first. Then they announced they were going to try for Sunday, June 21st in Burgenstock, Switzerland. The strait opened on June 20th with 55 commercial vessels successfully moving 17 million barrels of oil.

Then something happened that ruined nearly all the progress–shots started firing in southern Lebanon and it caused Iran to shut the strait immediately. Most of what this essay will discuss is how we can answer the classic geopolitical whodunnit, or better put, whostartedit.

To get the facts straight before I establish a timeline (please, ignore the order in which I write these facts! It does not mean anything): (a) Hezbollah forces in Lebanon at some point on June 20th began firing on Israel. (b) Israel began firing on southern Lebanon with 50 rocket launches. (c) Hezbollah claims Israel encroached the ceasefire border, thus causing them to fire the initial rounds.

Ok, I hope I did that part without scary any demagogues away…hardest part over. Now let’s talk about the classic geopolitical paradox of:

He Said, She Said.

There is an oft-recurring dynamic on geopolitics and conflict that we can observe in the Middle East, and specifically, with Israel in its relation to its most frequent belligerents. We can look at this latest spat of Israeli-Hezbollah conflict. Hezbollah claims Israel encroached on a ceasefire line, incurring a structural disruption. Hezbollah then took it upon themselves to begin kinetic warfare by launching shells–otherwise known as tactical disruption. All of the statements just listed can be verifiably falsified; in other words, all of these facts are right v. wrong. True v. false. That’s a good thing. We want to reduce conflicts like this to a set of provable facts, and seek out the truth.

Assume Israel did encroach on Lebanese territory “first” (although I am by no means suggesting this is the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth): Hezbollah would argue this is a structural disruption that qualifies as “starting it,” but many Americans and Israelis would claim that walking over a line in the sand isn’t the same “it” being started as launching projectiles at apartment buildings. It’s a frame incongruency–a semantic disagreement, and yet, it still leads to ceasefires that are carrying the weight of hundreds of billions of dollars in world trade and tens of thousands of lives to snap like a twig.

For this reason, we must learn to ask the following two questions, instead of an oversimplified one: (1) who initiated the structural disruption or diversion from the expected course of action following a ceasefire or agreement and (2) who was the first military belligerent to utilize violence against the other party. More often than not, the answers to (1) and (2) will be different parties. They will be (2) David and (1) Goliath.

(Brief insertion: in the above David and Goliath paradigm, Israel is Goliath. This is often true for conflicts between Israel and terrorist or insurgency groups, but this is not true universally. Although Israel has military might and the backing of the United States, for much of the 20th century it was a lone party in a war against the entirety of the Arabic Middle East. There are approx. 10 million Jews on the planet. That’s about 1/10th of the population of Iran, and 1/100th of the total Muslim population.)

In these circumstances, not only do David and Goliath commit unique disruptive acts but they have unique motives, too. There are three primary reasons why the David group may choose to commit a tactical disruption: (1) they want to call attention to their cause on a global stage because they find the status quo under a preexisting ceasefire to be intolerable, (2) they cannot match a state military in conventional war so they must utilize surprise to inflict economic and psychological harm, and (3) there may be an alternative leadership rebel group trying to seize power and so the ruling rebel group must show an active resistance to regather the support of the people. Goliath wants a few things: (1) they want restored deterrence–don’t just hit back with commensurate force, but hit back hard enough to make them think twice before they strike again. (2) Domestically, politicians must show their citizens that they know no bounds, and will stop at no end, in order to keep them safe from even minor border infringement. (3) Goliath will use these disruptions begun by the David group to “mow the grass” and trim down military infrastructure of the enemy, causing an extended period of peace not by choice, but by circumstance.

Who Can We Trust?

In order to get a better understanding of what is going on, we need to consult with the most reliable sources. An example is UNIFIL (United Nations Interim Force in Lebanon) who keep detailed seismic and radar tracking. You can also look at data aggregators like ACLED and Airwars.

The Frame Incongruency Problem

The “who started it” question is a question that neither party wants you to be able to answer. During a war, or some form of military conflict, there is one thing that the belligerents on each end have in common–something that both the Iranian generals and the Israeli generals can both claim with validity: they benefit from the gears turning on the military apparatus. This is maybe the fundamental issue of war; those who are trained and tooled to end it, often feel that their personal power, sovereignty, influence, and career is dependent on its extension. Thus there is constant conflict about whether peace is actually the “right” path. Wartime budgets expand fast and contract slowly; no government wants to be the government to cut defense spending while actively under attack. The greater the budget (meaning more contracts to dish out, more generals to promote) the more powerful the military leaders. The IDF has a similar structure in which the reservist mobilization is the new standard, and there exist many military leaders who would not be in the military at all were it not for the war time posture. This means that for many, peace is a demotion.

Both the IDF and the IRGC (Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps) have operational promotion policies. This means you get promoted on your operational record–a record that cannot be developed or improved during peacetime. Then, there is domestic political survival. Prime Minister of Israel, Benjamin Netanyahu, is a prime example. He is electorally and politically inclined to continue the war–it is likely the only thing keeping him in office. And yet, his job, more than anything else, is to end the war.

This ongoing conflict for many military leaders – “to fight or not to fight” – wherein they already hold an inclination to strike back when struck, regardless of how little or how light, is the same mechanism that pushes them to overreact in the David and Goliath instances. When Israel steps over a borderline, the IRGC feels affronted. Hezbollah attacks, because that’s what they’ve been taught to do. Then, Israel attacks tenfold, because that is their job. This cycle continues, on, and on, and on, until something changes materially. Not something between these nations, because the root cause of this spiral isn’t international, but rather it’s domestic: it’s a systems question. We need to edit the mandate for militaries – we need to invest more in our defense departments during peacetime, and perhaps less during wartime. We need to insulate our military leaders from the employment threat of peace.

Thanks for reading folks & happy fathers day!

–J&E