The “Strong American Consumer” is as Fake as Santa Claus
Every holiday season, Wall Street puts on its Santa hat to welcome the Santa Claus Rally. It’s the idea that stocks tend to rise in the last trading days of December and the first few of January. At the same time, economists pace nervously over how much people are spending — and where they’re spending it. Between skyrocketing holiday retail figures, booming consumer debt, and a surge in Buy Now, Pay Later (BNPL) usage, the waters are muddied: is strength something we can depend or just a Christmas Miracle?
This year, everything feels bigger — the numbers, the narratives, and the stakes. Let’s unwrap where this tradition came from, what the data really says about consumer behavior, and why the markets and spending patterns are telling a story that isn’t quite as straightforward as “Americans are back to spending like they used to.”
The Santa Claus Rally: A Bit of History
The term “Santa Claus Rally” was popularized in the early 1970s by Yale Hirsch of the Stock Trader’s Almanac. What he and other market historians noticed was a recurring pattern: in many years, stock prices appeared to climb during the last five trading days of December and the first two trading days of January. Over the long haul — going back to the mid-20th century — this period has historically been positive more often than not. Since 1950, studies show the S&P 500 has produced gains during this window about 76–79% of the time, with average returns of around +1.3% in that brief stretch.
There are a few explanations for why this pattern might exist:
Low trading volume: Many institutional traders take time off, reducing liquidity and making it easier for prices to move on less capital.
Year-end flows: Portfolio managers rebalance or put capital to work ahead of the new year. (Note how you might assume positions get closed at the end of the year, but no! There is actually minimal take-profits.)
Holiday optimism: There’s a psychological effect– both from consumers and investors– that overlaps with seasonal goodwill.
That said, not every year delivers a rally, and the pattern is far from ironclad. Some research suggests that the gains attributed to a Santa rally are modest or even negligible in certain timeframes, and that they can just as easily be statistical noise.
But tradition is powerful in markets. So the markets continue trading ever-so-slightly up, year after year, and never question it. “Maybe,” traders tell themselves, “it’s the Wall Street version of a gift from Santa!”
But here’s the danger. We’re at a junction in the international and domestic economy where things can go two ways — Good and Bad (with capital G and capital B). Every piece of data is vital to understanding that direction—including market reactions to economic releases. So don’t confuse a small present from Santa with a sign that the economy is A-OK—he’s not that powerful.
Consumer Spending: Strong Numbers,
The narrative of a “resilient consumer” has taken root in financial media: holiday spending is up, retail foot traffic is strong, and credit card balances are climbing. Indeed, holiday retail spending and consumer spending in general have accelerated; one report notes holiday retail sales jumped about 4.2%, driven by e-commerce and electronics purchases.
And according to recent estimates, total holiday spending by American consumers is expected to pass $1 trillion this season — a landmark figure that would exceed historical peaks.
When looked at deeper, we are met with a harsher reality: not all spending is created equal, and the distribution of that spending is increasingly skewed.
So Who’s Really Spending?
Major consumer spending figures often mask uneven behavior across income groups. In other words, the average consumer might look like they’re spending more — but that average is pulled up by a smaller fraction of affluent households.
The top 10% of earners make up roughly 50% of all consumer spending. That is the highest number in history. For context, 30 years ago, the top 10% made up just a third.
Gallup polling from October found that while the average estimated holiday spend per person was similar to last year, lower-income households actually expect to spend less year-over-year, while higher-income consumers expect to spend more. Specifically, households earning over $100,000 anticipate spending nearly $1,500, up from about $1,400 the previous year, while those under $50,000 expect their holiday spending to shrink by more than $100.
Aggregate spending growth doesn’t necessarily mean broad-based economic strength — it can just as easily reflect the disproportionate spending power of higher-income earners. That difference matters for the structure of consumption, the health of the labor market, and how retail earnings actually translate into macroeconomic momentum.
In other words: the wealthy are propping up headline figures.
Quick Note For Investors: This is a SERIOUS tailwind for luxury stocks. Why? Because the second and third-order effects of an economy where an increasing portion of the disposable income is spent by the ultra-wealthy, than that means (in $ terms) an increasing share of disposable income will be spent on ultra-wealthy needs (otherwise known as F-You money luxury). Check out the businesses around today that have a) an infrastructure and b) a societal flag as an “achievement purchase” for the increasingly dominant ultra-wealthy class.
Buy Now, Pay Later: A Signal of Strain
One of the most revealing trends under the surface of “strong” holiday spending is the explosion in Buy Now, Pay Later (BNPL) services.
BNPL has been around for over a decade, but its adoption has surged in recent years thanks to integration with online checkout flows and aggressive marketing to younger consumers. Modern BNPL allows shoppers to split purchases into short-term installment plans with minimal upfront cost, blurring the line between a purchase and a loan.
According to industry data, the use of BNPL grew rapidly during the pandemic and has continued to expand. By late 2024 and into 2025, nearly one in five credit-active U.S. consumers had used BNPL, with usage especially high among younger and more financially pressured households.
During the holiday season, BNPL activity tends to spike — people are buying gifts, often under tight budgets. But that spike doesn’t necessarily reflect confident consumers; rather, it reflects consumers who don’t have the cash on hand but still want to participate in the holiday shopping wave. According to Lending Tree, default rates are accelerating: 42% of BNPL users made at least one late payment in 2025, up from 39% in 2024 and 34% in 2023
.
The growth of BNPL use in essentials like groceries also tells a deeper story. A growing share of grocery purchases — traditionally a non-discretionary category — is being financed through these micro-loans, which suggests households are increasingly relying on credit to cover basic expenses.
In economic terms, record BNPL adoption during strong consumer spending periods can be a leading indicator of stress, not strength.
What This Means for Markets and the Economy
So how do we reconcile strong headline spending with underlying fragility?
One way to think about it is to separate narratives from mechanics:
Headlines talk about total holiday retail spending topping records and bullish market behavior.
But underlying trends suggest that spending growth is unevenly distributed — solid among wealthier households and highly leveraged among lower-income ones.
This creates a kind of artificial-support effect in macro data: consumption looks strong, but the strength is concentrated and propped up by credit usage that may not be sustainable long-term.
Markets like stories that are easy to tell: strong spending should mean strong earnings should mean higher valuations. But in this cycle, earnings may be driven by an even narrower set of consumers, while the majority of households are increasingly turning to debt to keep pace.
Markets may rally, consumers may swipe, and economists may argue — but Christmas still arrives on schedule. However you’re reading this data, I hope you’re doing it somewhere warm, well-fed, and offline for a moment or two. Happy holidays, and here’s to a new year with clearer signals and fewer illusions.
Merry Christmas and Happy Hanukkah!
—J&E