San Francisco's summer music fests divide neighbors - Axios San Francisco

In 2025, moviegoers in the US and Canada bought 769.2 million tickets, about two per person. This is less than half of the amount bought in 2002. Ticket sales are down 40% since 2019. The COO of Alamo Drafthouse said, “the industry just flatlined.”

Books aren’t much better. 36% Americans say they read fewer books than they did a decade ago. Accounting for inflation, book sales are shrinking.

Live events don’t look great either (just keep reading, trust me). Gen Z drinks less, does fewer drugs, is lonelier, has less sex, and prefers to sit at home alone. Only 39% are interested in attending music festivals, whereas 46% said they were in 2019. More than 12% of US nightclub venues closed within two years. More than a third of Brits between 16 and 24 years of age didn’t drink once in 2021. Restaurant traffic fell every month of 2025 except for July. Large chains are closing locations. Six Flags, and other theme parks, are bleeding. US inbound tourism is falling. Airlines are seeing less flights. Malls are closing. Print newspaper circulation is down 60% since 2000 (which makes me so sad). CDs are dead, vinyl is seemingly dead. Golf is withering away, with courses closing every month. Board games are in decline.

According to our Seesaw Theory, all of these legacy categories are going to experience growth directly correlated to the diffusion of AI and other forms of technology.

The Argument

What we’ve observed among young people around the country is clear: the more technology invades our everyday lives, via social media, streaming, chatbots, AVs, etc…the more people become economically rebellious. They engage in what we call, “throw your phone out the window consumerism.”

This is incredibly difficult to model by our traditional economic formulas. It is an inherently inefficient decision on behalf of the consumer. A good way to put it is, the friction is the feature. Consumers are seeking out experiences where they have to work for something, they have to use their hands to leaf through the pages or walk down the street to the movie theater, and they feel more reward when engaging in these things.

Our Seesaw Theory contends that the more people are inundated with technology in their professional and personal lives (both with and against their will), the more they will seek out legacy, intergenerationally nostalgic, human-to-human, and digitally irreplicable experiences and products.

Historical Precedent

Vinyl.

Vinyl is an interesting example of this. It appeared to be lifeless. By 2004, vinyl was 0.2% of total US recorded music revenue. Now, in 2025, it’s up 9.3% YoY and is in the 19th consecutive year of growth. It’s never going to reach it’s prior heights of the 20th century, but that doesn’t mean it’s dead. Vinyl is now about 7.5% of US recorded music revenue. Everything is relative; when there is an product or brand that will never reach #1 in market share, but it’s being priced for the #100 slot and has potential to hit the #5 slot, there is a huge opportunity. Pricing is relative, and therefore returns are relative to a divergence in reality and expectations.

Gen Z is playing an outsize role in this trend with their purchases growing an average 18% every year over the past five years. About 60% of Gen Z claims to buy records. Gen Z is 27% more likely than the average music consumer to buy vinyl, despite being born into a Spotify era.

Quartz and mechanical watches.

Japanese quartz made mechanical watches obsolete overnight: it was better on price, accuracy, and reliability. Swiss employment collapsed by two-thirds and the total number of firms decreased.

And yet, Swiss watchmaking came back stronger than ever. Not as the most effective form of timekeeping, but a bespoke and handmade analog industry where the beauty of the product was the inefficiency and the irrationality. That’s why people spend tens of thousands or more on these products, despite having MUCH cheaper alternatives.

Farmers markets.

With the advent of McDonald’s and fast food, people assumed that local food and farmers were, in a single word, screwed. And yet, in reaction to the opening of a McDonald’s at the Spanish Steps, farmers markets began to crop up out of protest.

In the US, farmers markets grew from under 2,000 USDA registered in the 1990s, to over 8,000. The human-to-human and friction nature of the model is the product itself; people are paying a premium to watch someone grab a massive wad of cheese out of a cooler, from a cow they probably raised themselves, and hand it over for some obscene price.

Craft beer.

During a fully flat period for the beer industry, and with more consolidation among the large beer suppliers, the number of breweries went from under 100 to over 9,000. This is an example of premiumization and the emphasis of ritual and human touch.

Polaroid.

Polaroid stopped making instant film and group of people bought the last factory, termed the “impossible project,” and eventually bought back the entire brand and built a terrific business.

Thanks for reading Passing the Torch Newsletter! This post is public so feel free to share it.

Why are people so upset?

People are incredibly frustrated with AI, and the way its becoming a very noticeable part of our lives, sometimes against our will.

Why is this? I don’t think it’s very hard to explain. We have a great article, linked below, about how AI is suffering a “death by a thousand cuts.” It’s not just the potential risk (I say potential, because it isn’t very manifest just yet) of losing your job or having killer robots murder us all; it’s the reality that when you walk in the subway station all you see is nonsense B2B AI ads, and that when you visit your grandma for dinner she asks how to use this “ChatPGT” thing, and your boss forces you to go to a new “AI Training” seminar every month, all of which are likely useless. It’s the little things that drive us crazy. That’s how AI is ruining it’s reputation.

As awareness of AI grows, with 47% surveyed by Pew aware of the tech versus only 26% in 2022*, the favorability of the tech continues to plummet. NBC reports that 57% of people think AI risks outweigh the benefits.

*I would like to point out in the Pew survey I reference, there are 5% of people with zero awareness of AI in 2025. I rarely use the phrase “living under a rock,” but…what the hell are you doing all day?

Is this just a theory or is there data?

Of course data lags the trend, and we think we’re early here. Most data still indicates strength in AI products and pain in the legacy and analog world. Some interesting insight comes from the fact that the WSJ and other mainstream news outlets are starting to put this all together, though. See below very recent articles (we keep this list updated) of folks who essentially are making the same argument as us…

“Investors are looking for opportunities insulated from the AI boom, including businesses built around human experiences that ChatGPT can’t replace.” — WSJ

“the collective, united anger at tech companies is really remarkable.” — WSJ

We think it is not a coincidence that we are seeing earnings upsets and unexpected strength in the human-to-human and live experience markets, during a period of more tech diffusion than ever. We think this link is extremely underexplored.

How do you play this?

  • Live music: concerts, festivals, residencies

  • Movie theaters: regular screenings, especially mods like 70MM

  • Broadway and live theater

  • Stand-up comedy: arena comedy is the new class

  • Live sports attendance and minor leagues like banana ball

  • Theme parks

  • Museums, galleries, and blockbuster exhibitions

  • Live podcast tapings and author events: parasocial relationships are huge, which we will discuss soon

  • Religious services

  • Weddings and formal events

  • Supper clubs, chef’s counters, and tasting menus

  • Food halls and night markets

  • Karaoke, mini-golf, darts and billiards, bowling, golf

  • Escape rooms, immersive experiences

  • Run clubs, marathons, Hyrox, obstacle courses, Iron Man

  • Dance classes, climbing gyms, pilates, yoga, workout classes, rec sports leagues

  • Vinyl records and turntables

  • Physical books and independent bookstores

  • Film photography

  • CDs and cassettes

  • DVDs and Blu-rays

  • Print magazines

  • Boardgames and RPGs

  • Trading cards and TCGs

  • Mechanical watches

  • Fountain pens, stationery, paper planners, journals and notebooks

  • Analog music instruments

  • Secondhand and vintage fashion

  • Dumbphones and minimalist tech

  • Retro gaming

  • Puzzles, model kits, LEGO

  • Independent coffee shops

  • Craft breweries and non-alcoholic craft

  • Bakeries and artisan food

  • Butchers, farmers markets

  • Pottery studios, woodworking classes

  • Tattoo industry

  • Bespoke tailoring

  • National parks and hiking

  • Camping and RVs

  • Fishing, hunting, foraging

  • Skiing, surfing, outdoor sports

  • Gardening

  • Wellness retreats, silent retreats, digital detox

  • Saunas and bathhouses

  • Long haul trains

  • Cruises

  • Boutique hotels

  • Libraries

  • etc…

We’ve got theses on all of these. Going to write about them each soon. Please email me at [email protected] if you’d like to talk about any particular one. Love to talk about what we’re seeing.

Thanks for reading, and as always, stay curious folks!

A note on our usage of AI: we do not use AI to write our articles. You can check. I recommend you also check the other Substacks you subscribe to, and I bet they likely do. If you want to support people who do the hard work of actually creating high quality reporting and opinion for you, please consider signing up for PTT Pro.

—J&E