This article is Part 2, or rather, a rebuttal, to Emile’s prior post linked below. Please read if you have not yet. It is free.

To start with an abridged version to remind you of Emile’s argument in the article linked above: humans are afraid of being insignificant, and so we argue that AI can’t match us because of that fear. The world is deterministic, all variables are encoded for and everything is mechanical. We are just a cog in a system over which we have no oversight or dominion.

My reply: nope (said with my chest).

It’s going to be a bit tricky to define to you exactly what I believe humanity’s fairy dust is (that’s my term of choice), so I’m going to give you some examples instead. I can’t really tell you what makes you feel most human but I’ll start with myself. Maybe some of you will see where I’m coming from. (If this article is boring you already, please please keep reading. This one is maybe the best one I’ve ever written).

I went golfing yesterday. I was so excited and so happy. Carrying the clubs made me smile. Driving the ball made me smile. My brain was overflowing with joy and excitement. I was content and everything felt just right. Emile would tell me that this was chemical; biological; it’s all just consequence of evolution. Someone please tell me: how does going to Dyker to hit 110 on a Par 72, lose two dozen balls, get seven mosquito bites, and a mean sunburn, produce in an evolutionary sense? Nothing. I was with friends, sure. That might have a distant evolutionary basis. But I think I felt connected; to them, to the other people who love this new sport I’m getting into, to my relatives who’ve played this sport, and I just felt something that even I, the most remarkable writer on the Internet, can’t really articulate. This is just a silly example.

Here’s another unserious one. I am weirdly obsessed with Uber Blacks. I know that sounds obnoxious. First order of business—no, my parents never pay for them. Now that we’ve gotten that out of the way…there is just something I love about a cool, comfortable, hulking Cadillac driving you through the streets of NYC. I have no clue why I’m so ready to part with my money for this, but I am. It’s one of those (not-so-little) pleasures that make us who we are. That’s human, not scientific. That’s special sauce.

I think that our unique variable, the H-factor, is probably immaterial (and therefore, the physical sciences are never going to figure it out). This isn’t really my domain of expertise, although I’m always trying to read other people’s thoughts on these questions. I will say that philosophy will become an incredibly lucrative field in the age of AI.

Let’s talk about something a little more serious. When you look into a great piece of art, take Van Gogh’s Starry Night as an example, you feel something. You can understand by reading the brushstrokes what his mind sounded like, and how his heart felt. You can feel the air on his easel as he painted. If you put these works side by side with his others, you can begin to see him change; he matures, then he devolves, and then he reaches a brink of no return. You can view this man’s life without words, and without logic. That’s the key. There is no logic, at least consciously, to a good reading of a piece of art. The same goes for music; lyrics are often a distant second to the feelings of the sounds. The skill to do that, to “put yourself in someone’s shoes,” to put it childishly, is humanity. AI doesn’t have that and it simply cannot have that. It requires an understanding of suffering and beauty learned by experience in your own life, to understand the suffering and beauty in someone else’s. The question to ask isn’t, “Can AI make Starry Night?” but rather, “Does AI understand Starry Night?” And if it weren’t for humans writing their interpretations on the Internet, or into the training data, then no it couldn’t and it’d never be able to.

It’s like asking an orangutan to write a scientific research paper on mating, or on nutritional science. It just doesn’t have the vocabulary to do that. That by no means suggests that it isn’t able to eat or to…you know…We humans don’t really understand what’s going on here or inside but we do know how to use it, and how to feel it; we know how to wield it.

For this reason I think AI Slop is one of the most grave dangers of the 21st century. We must protect, at all costs, our viewing and understanding muscle. We must look at art and read fiction and feel it. That’s the only “moat” that human beings have. Technically, AI can “make” anything. Art is just pixels arranged in a specific way. But it has no clue what the hell it’s doing. It has nothing driving it forward, besides an instruction or some preprogrammed incentive.

I really mean it. I want all of you to find time today, or this week, to exercise your humanity. Here are a couple ways I’ve found to do that: look at photos and videos of yourself from when you were a young child. Think about how you feel, and notice the lack of words you’re equipped with to describe that feeling. Call someone that you haven’t spoken to in decades, that you were once very close with. Sit on the sidewalk in NYC and watch people go about their lives, and wonder what their stories might be. Be sad. Be happy. Be proud. Think about someone who’s no longer in your life, and remember the moments (both good and bad) from when they were. Most important: don’t make something. Don’t write, or draw, or talk, or sing. Just think about it. Keep it to yourself, because we don’t really have language for these feelings and that’s the whole point.

I really believe in what I’m saying here. I think we ought to live our lives chasing as much “fairy dust” as we can. We’re human and our imperative, albeit sometimes ill-defined, is to be human. A nice mantra is that there’s no good or bad decisions in life, besides choosing to not live it to the fullest extent. I’m not asking you to go skydiving; that’s too mechanical and predictable. Do something so unique and weird that I couldn’t even imagine telling you to do it. Float around in the whirlwind that is the thoughts in your head for a while, and have some fun doing it. Don’t be so afraid of it, because you’re going to need to cherish it in this AI era.

AI doesn’t die, but we do. That means AI will never be able to live. But we can. No matter what you do, don’t forget that you’re privileged to be touched with “fairy dust.” Go have some fun with it.

Thanks for reading, and as always, stay curious folks!

—J&E

Thanks for reading Passing the Torch Newsletter! This post is public so feel free to share it.