After President Donald Trump proposed capping credit card interest rates at 10%, bank executives lined up to deliver their warnings. JPMorgan CFO Jeremy Barnum warned that “people will lose access to credit, on a very, very extensive and broad basis, especially the people who need it.” Translation: young people with thin credit files won’t be getting cards anymore.
The Young and the Creditless
The Electronic Payments Coalition, which represents financial institutions and payment card networks, said that nearly every credit card account associated with a credit score below 740—82% to 88% of open credit card accounts—would be closed or severely restricted under a 10% cap. To put that in context, the widely accepted figure for the average credit score for Gen Z is around 680.
The banks aren’t entirely wrong to worry, even if their protestations sound like a landlord complaining about rent control. A rate cap would fundamentally alter the risk-reward calculus that makes lending to young, unproven borrowers profitable. Banks price risk into interest rates. Cap the upside, and the marginal borrower suddenly becomes uneconomical to serve. Banks, in other words, are saying this: if we can’t charge you 24% when you miss a payment, we’re not going to take the chance on you at all. Or in even simpler (and harsher) terms: if we can’t f*** you over, we don’t want your business.
Gen Z needs credit more than anyone, yet they’re the least equipped to get it. Nearly 62% lack emergency savings—double the rate of baby boomers. When financial disaster strikes (and it will), one in four say they’d max out their credit cards to survive. According to Talker Research, Gen Z currently averages a staggering $94,101 in personal debt; close to the combined amount of both millennials ($59,181) and Gen X ($53,255). You could dismiss this as youthful financial recklessness, but the numbers sing a different tune. Over 30% of Gen Z cardholders use credit for everyday items like gas and groceries, higher than any other generation (CreditOne).
The credit card has become the emergency fund that this generation never had time to build. And now, that lifeline might get yanked away. We’re not saying this lifeline should continue to exist, or should have ever existed in the first place, we’re just pleading that President Trump understand the ramifications of his actions for young people.
The Industries Caught in the Crossfire
Let’s begin with the bears: if Gen Z can’t borrow, they won’t spend. And if they won’t spend, you’re in trouble. The simple question to ask yourself is what happens when a generation suddenly can’t finance its lifestyle? Look at where Gen Z spends. They dominate spending in categories like skincare, fashion, beauty, and health and wellness—all very discretionary. Retailers in the fashion and apparel space should also be worried. Gen Z already cut overall spending by 13% in early 2025, with apparel and electronics taking the hardest hits. These are sectors built on short term impulses. In fact, Vanquis revealed that Gen Z makes double the impulsive purchases of the average person. Credit cards can be seen as what enables that impulse. BNPL can too, but the spending ceiling is lower, and the friction slightly higher. Every small barrier matters when margins are razor-thin.
Gen Z also favors experiences over objects: travel, dining, entertainment. These purchases are often paid for using credit to stretch limited disposable income. Credit card rewards also drive many popular airline loyalty programs. Delta CEO Ed Bastian warned that a rate cap would “upend the whole credit card industry,” threatening the $8.2 billion in annual revenue Delta earns through its American Express partnership.
But one man’s bear is another man’s bull. When traditional credit becomes scarce, alternatives flourish. The American Bankers Association warned that a rate cap would “drive consumers toward less regulated, more costly alternatives.” They meant it as a threat, and they are probably right. BNPL companies like Affirm, Klarna, and Afterpay must be watching this unfold with barely concealed glee. A 10% credit card cap swings open a cathedral-sized opportunity for an industry that thrives on the financially precarious while closing another one in traditional credit cards. And god forbid we see a surge in payday loans…
Buy Now, Pay Later already accounts for 1.5% to 2.5% of all transactions, but among Gen Z, the penetration runs far deeper. Some 64% have tried it at least once. More troublingly, over 40% have made a late payment, up seven points from a year earlier. (LendingTree)
Tickers to look out for:
- Snapchat
- Klarna
- Affirm
- Ulta Beauty
- Best Buy
- Match (Tinder)
- Pinterest
- Roblox
- Lululemon
- American Eagle Outfitters
Forced Financial Maturity?
But perhaps there’s something almost Darwinian about all this. Gen Z has been stereotyped as financially reckless, chronically online, allergic to delayed gratification, and more than anything… lazy. Maybe a credit crunch is exactly what we need—a forced education in living within their means.
Without access to credit cards, spending decisions become immediate and binary. You either have the money, or you don’t. No more gray area. For a generation that runs out of money almost every month (41%), the loss of credit might paradoxically simplify their financial lives.
But let’s also remind ourselves that Gen Z inherited an economy where real wages haven’t kept pace with housing costs, where a college degree guarantees debt but not opportunity, where the S&Ps has 25x price to earnings, where gig work masquerades as entrepreneurship. We were certainly not born with economic nihilism…its a learned trait.
And there’s precedent for this. After the 2008 financial crisis, credit dried up for millions. It was painful. But it also reset spending habits, forced household deleveraging, and ultimately contributed to a more stable (if unequal) recovery. Gen Z might experience their own, albeit less devastating, version: a clarifying moment where access to easy capital evaporates and they’re left to rebuild with what they actually have.
History has a funny way of making people resilient through deprivation. The Silent Generation emerged from the Great Depression with a pathological commitment to frugality. Boomers who came of age during stagflation learned to hedge. Millennials, burned by 2008, became hyper-aware of debt traps even as they drowned in student loans. Gen Z could follow a similar trajectory, with the loss of credit access being the first step.
In that sense, the fight over credit cards is really a referendum on the kind of capitalism young people are inheriting. A system that taught Gen Z to rely on debt to bridge structural gaps in wages, housing, and stability is now debating whether they’re even worth lending to at all. And if that credit really disappears, young people will certainly feel it, and it’ll confirm that the economy never intended to build durable financial footing for its youngest participants in the first place.
See ya, folks. Stay curious.
-- J&E