![A Timeline of America's Trendiest Energy Drink Brands [Infographic] | VinePair](https://media.beehiiv.com/cdn-cgi/image/fit=scale-down,quality=80,format=auto,onerror=redirect/uploads/asset/file/cb5e28f6-f8b4-4f07-a807-c3680673e6ef/0e4133f6-4c9e-45df-9789-0fe39298eade_1000x1000.jpg?t=1794438182)
Energy drinks are still an incredibly fast-growing category. It’s priced to grow. We believe that the energy drink market, specifically Celsius and other new(er) brands, are incredibly vulnerable to regulatory and cultural risk surrounding health factors that are abundantly documented and yet, unpriced. We have a very important and previously unknown anecdote and trend to unearth, to better prove this argument and the mechanism that will bite the brands.
What makes us say this now?
We are seniors in high school, as you all likely know. This gives us an interesting window into certain trends, before they begin to appear in data reads. We try and flag everything we notice in our day-to-day life (a life which, I might add, not a single other equity research writer or sell-side analyst has access to) and come up with a takeaway that has implications for investors. We were at a kickoff meeting with our entire high school, led by our principal, last week, and a flag went up…a pretty big one, that we didn’t see coming.
As she ran through the typical reminders that we receive at the start of every year (no running in the halls, don’t be late to class, weekly morning meetings with your grade, etc…), there was a new slide appended to the presentation: energy drinks. Now, our school has always had a strict policy against any illicit substance: zero alcohol, nicotine, marijuana, or other drug is allowed on the premises and discovery results in expulsion (or something like it). But this slide was about energy drinks, and caffeine—a substance humans have been consuming (teenagers and adults alike) for centuries if not longer. They said: “After seeing scientific research noting the damages of energy drinks that contain 200mg of caffeine or more, we very nearly made the decision to ban them in school. For the time being, we’ve decided that you may have them but we advise against it, and if we see you with one consistently, we will reach out to inform your parents.” OK. Weird, right?
This means the school is essentially viewing high caffeine content energy drinks as an illicit substance. They DID NOT mention coffee, tea, or anything of the like. This was targeted to energy drinks. The slide they showed displayed Alani, Bloom, Celsius, and Red Bull. The message was very clear, and I think it really matters. If our school is doing this, I doubt they’re the only ones. So this got me interested…
Is this happening?
If you look to Europe, you can see that the age-restrictions have been happening, and it’s speeding up. Lithuania was the first to ban for under 18, and now Latvia, Romania, Hungary, Poland, Albania, Croatia, and Belarus have joined them. Norway is banning for those under the age of 16. Spain is nearing a ban.
More interestingly, England plans to ban for under 16 starting in April of 2027. Consider the fact that the United States has a drinking age of 21, whereas most European nations have one at 18. This means that in Europe, an energy drink is on par with an alcoholic drink. Might the US follow this path?
Quebec’s Health Minister has flagged this as an issue and started a bill. So has the US FDA, which has named it as a priority.
States are starting to consider this issue in the US.
California passed AB 1264 in October of 2025 which bans caffeinated beverage sales in schools. Suffolk County has a law that prohibits sale of these drinks in public parks. But nothing material has passed.
Delaware HB 394 bans the sale of drinks with more than 100mg of caffeine per 8 ounces (basically all energy drinks), but it still sits in the House Health and Human Development Committee. Massachusetts HB 1908 bans sale to minors, and has been sent to study. Connecticut, New York, Indiana, and Maine have also raised bills banning sales to those under the age of 16.
H.R. 2511 in the House, the Sarah Katz Caffeine Safety Act, would require labeling that notes warnings and dangers of drinks with extreme levels of caffeine. Several US states have put waivers on energy drinks through SNAP: Arkansas, Louisiana, Montana, Nebraska, North Dakota, South Carolina, and Tennessee.
Regulation is happening in schools, largely from the bottom-up. Nurses are noticing issues, and telling their administrators. Texas is the epicenter of this issue. Gladewater, Diboll, Lampasas, and McGregor ISDs all banned the drinks on campus. Missouri and Kentucky are seeing campus bans also. These bans are starting with nurses noticing more frequent visits for jitteriness, panic attacks, and heart palpitations. The bans are generally stemming from health advisory councils, not school boards.
Although students can still grab an energy drink on the way to school in any state in the United States, the stigma around the drinks is building.
This is giving me throwbacks.
Think back to the achingly slow, but massively impactful, fight against cigarettes. Mind you, this fight basically killed the industry. It started with a report from the Surgeon General in 1964. Packs contained labels starting in 1966. We are at this point with energy drinks.
Then, in 1997, the Joe Camel mascot was retired under pressure that it was marketed to kids. This became a major flashpoint in the argument. A Delaware resident actually said that energy drinks are the “Joe Camel of our age.” With smoking, bans started at the local and institutional level. Then came the AGs and litigation which is actively happening with Ken Paxton’s investigation, and slowly, age limits tightened until the industry was ruined. Taxes didn’t help.
The two key counterarguments are that (a) health evidence around the energy drink risk is not as strong as that around cigarettes, and (b) coffee has been normalizing caffeine for centuries.
I just think it’s an interesting parallel.
What does this mean for Celsius stock?
Celsius stock is trading around $28 a share right now. It’s lost about 50% over the past twelve months. There is some pricing in of the reg risk we just talked about, but the vast majority of the pain has been rooted in fundamentals…eroding brand (Q2 missed expectations, with Celsius brand sales down more than 11%), compressed margins at 22.5% EBITDA margin from 28.5% in the prior period, and costs rising from fuel and freight inputs. Following the announcement of the Rodriguez lawsuit in Texas, wherein a 17-year old child died of alleged heart failure after drinking the Celsius product, the stock only fell 4%. This is a big lawsuit. 4% doesn’t fully reflect that, in my opinion. Alani Nu, a recently acquired energy drink brand, seems to be the presumptive saving grace for the business. In my view, Alani Nu is just as, if not more exposed, to all of the reg. risk factors we’ve already discussed…and it’s going to continue to be a product where more market share comes from under-18 consumers than any energy drink prior.
There’s a couple ways the risk could play out:
(1) the best-case for CELH
The Ken Paxton litigation is purely political, and headline news. He settles for a nominal fee in the $10 million range, and some very minor restrictions. It goes away. No bans or age restrictions are passed in the US. No more schools restrict the drink on campus.
(2) moderate case for CELH
There is a multistate case that leads to a larger settlement (somewhere in the range of $50-200 million) and more importantly, restricts marketing to children. This means less social media and influencer marketing, and less “fruity flavors.” This is an issue because Alani Nu, the primary growth engine of CELH as a corporation, grew 21% last quarter by attacking the young female audience. If that marketing is handicapped, all of the growth in that product could be put on pause.
(3) worst case for CELH
Broader bans begin to happen at the state level on Celsius and Alani Nu for under-18s. This scales across the nation. Assume 90% of under-18 sales disappear. If we think that (this is not public data, so we’ve tried our best to piece together stories from peers) 15-20% of the CELH revenue is coming from the under-18 audience, that is a $450-600 million hit to revenue. At 22ish% margins, that’s about a $100 million hit to earnings, or at their current multiples, about a $1.8 billion hit to market cap. That’s a 28% decline. And this situation is absolutely fathomable, and entirely discounted / ignored by the broader market.
Why might I be wrong?
Ken Paxton suit may be largely political in motivations.
US states are moving very slowly on regulation.
The stock is generally pretty cheap right now, against its peers.
CEO and other execs are buying shares at $27 and $28.
What to look out for…
Other states joining in the Texas suit or issuing subpoenas.
The Rodriguez appeal ruling
Delaware HB 394’s progress in the house.
England’s ban in April 2027, and what it’s impact is.
Risk factor language in forthcoming Celsius 10Qs.
Disclaimer: I, and PTT Media, may hold positions in the securities discussed. We are not investment advisors, and this is not investment advice. Please invest at your own discretion.
Thanks for reading, and as always, stay curious folks!
—J&E