
I was recently reading a piece on Mike Johnson, and the backlash he is facing from his party due to his seeming inability to maintain a consensus, pass a law, and frankly, get anything done at all. “This is a rare moment,” they say, “and we must take advantage of a united Congress and White House.” But it seems this moment of unity, whether you are “for” or “against” the policy views themselves, is useless.
I think this may be because the two-party system in which we current run candidates in the United States is the “worst of both worlds.” When you have a divided government: think a GOP-controlled Congress and a Democrat in the White House—you aren’t going to get a damn thing passed into law. Nothing will ever get done. The government will barely scrape by on operating as is, and the concept of changing anything for the better or fixing any unforeseen catastrophes is pie in the sky. But, once you have a united government, the cracks begin to form nevertheless. The far-right and the Freedom Caucus; those who believe that the election was illegitimate and those who believe it was perfectly just; the Republicans who are willing to eat whatever Trump feeds them and the Republicans who need to be a thorn in his side in order to get their name in the paper; the senators who are not planning on running again and must protect their legacy above party allegiance and the political aspirants who will leave morals and beliefs at the front door in order to get ahead.
This is to say—our government is never united. And that’s a good thing. Because the people they represent aren’t united, either. The United States of America is perhaps, more divided than ever before. And I’m not referring to the MSNow “polarization and the threat to democracy” talking points that we all know so well. I mean that we are divided, in a healthy way—better put, we are diverse. We are diverse in all regards, not just race and gender — interests and pet peeves, belief systems, “is a hot dog a sandwich or not,” etc…So in order to function as a democracy our elected leaders not only can, but must, be entirely different from each other and sometimes they must disagree.
That is not to deny the fact that what we have right now is not acceptable, nor is it tenable. I think the root of the issue is differentiating between the act of lawmaking and the act of politicking. The former, I believe, as I say in the title of this article, is the best job in the world.
What do I mean by lawmaking?
Think of a problem, any problem, in the whole world.
There is construction happening at the end of your block and it’s bringing rats.
If you were a lawmaker (although, more likely this would call for a city or state legislator), you can make a law for that. H.R. 100 — Ensuring the Cleanliness of Construction Sites for Surrounding Property Owners. AKA ECCSSPO. Bang. There you go. Time to politick!
Do the American people want this change to be incurred? Yes, it is abundantly likely that most people fall into the bucket of “I approve” or “I don’t give a shit.”
So this should be a freebee! Hurrah — we just passed a law that will make this country a better and more pleasant place.
But wait…there are construction lobbyists who are whispering to a handful of legislators that they don’t approve because it will decrease their margins and potentially lead to longer build times. And now the real estate investors are involved.
It’s ok. This Congress has 535 people — no way a few lobbyists can move the needle by currying favor with individuals, one at a time. As long as they don’t manage to get, say, half of those people into a room, all at once, and get them to report to one “big boss legislator” who tells them what they do and don’t believe in.
Oh wait…
So now, the bill is DOA because this huge block of voters is calling themselves the Rat Party, and they have central (unelected) leadership. This central leadership tells them what to do, and they listen because this central leadership has somehow ended up being the moral authority to half of Americans at the voting booth, give or take. This central leadership promotes them, endorses them, elevates them to senior roles, helps them to get a little more comfortable financially, and honestly, allows them to drop the whole “American frontiersman” act of standing alone for what you believe, because who even believes in that anyway.
In so many words, a bipartisan system allows for less powerful lawmakers to avoid severe stomach ulcers. Ok…fine. The lawmakers win here, the construction company is happy, and I’m a tad bummed because I didn’t get my bill through but it’s ok because my anti-rat party leadership will pat me on my back and make sure I’m driving home to a nice five-bedroom in the suburbs of DC.
Everybody wins, except: the American people. There are still rats everytime there is construction. No progress has been made.
That progress I refer to is not the “change” that modern-day liberalism refers to—it’s the change is necessary to avoid devolving into some idiot-society that can’t make the right decision when it smacks you in the face (for more, see: Idiocracy, with Dax Shepard. For more, see: American Politics, 2016-2026).
I’m going to continue thinking about how this system can be fixed going forward, because I’m a young person in awe of all the opportunity to make this country not just some morally amorphous “better” place like the Democratic Socialists refer to, but a “smarter” place, where we make the right and rational decision ipso facto purely on the basis of it being the right and rational decision.
For those of you who may find this interesting, here are some cool bills recently drafted that will likely succumb to the Capitol Hill carwash we discussed above:
I personally could spend hours reading this stuff.
Thanks for reading folks & as always, stay curious!
—J&E