I was speaking with a descendant of Franklin Delano Roosevelt. In case you weren’t sure, they’ve got a lot of money. They told me that their sister was renting an apartment in Brooklyn Heights. She was 26. Her parents were paying for her, or rather, Franklin was, and she was still choosing to rent not buy? Weird, I thought. So here we go…why are rich young people choosing to rent and not buy?

Housing costs are a major issue at the national level. The Harvard Youth Poll found that four in ten young Americans think that housing costs are snowballing into a national crisis. Housing ranks above every other issue, on importance, besides inflation. As many as two-thirds of Gen Z renters across the nation struggle to afford their rent. Troy Closson of the NYT wrote, “If every group of young people had its driving cause, this one’s might be boiled down to six words: the rent is too damn high.”

Gen Zers are struggling to afford their rent, but a lucky few come from generational wealth. The impact of rich moms and dads is greater in this economic cycle than ever before. So we can assume that those folks are lucky enough to not just afford rent, but use the Bank of Mom and Dad to put a down payment on a home. But no…here’s where it gets weird. Gen Z, and the millennials, are getting richer and still renting.

I’ll group these wealthy Gen Zers and young millennials into three categories: (1) the founder, who has lumpy but large cash flows, (2) the high-earner, like a tech engineer or lawyer, and (3) the family money kid. All three of these, it seems, increasingly prefer to rent.

The founder, now a common archetype, gets paid in liquidity events: a stock sale, an acquisition, an IPO. There is some overlap with the high-earner in tech: oftentimes the founder starts an AI or tech startup and cashes out in an IPO. The high-earner joins early, is paid well, and cashes out at the same IPO. Other high-earners are: Wall Street analysts (although these are getting increasingly less well-paid), lawyers at the top firms, and engineers at the largest tech companies, like Google, Meta, Microsoft, and Amazon.

Demographic (1) has probably had one or two liquidity events by this point, with an average cash out of a few million dollars. So they’ve got about $3 million to $10 million in the bank. Maybe some of it is tied up in stock still. Then, Demographic (2) is probably making between $180,000 and $1.2 million a year — a wide range, for sure, but the lower end accounts for investment banking analysts and associates at law firms who might see lower base salaries but bonuses of $100,000 or more in good years. We are currently most interested in those who have capacity and lack propensity to buy a home.

Now, Demographic (3) might be the most interesting. The Great Wealth Transfer, the term for the passing of wealth from Baby Boomers to their children and grandchildren, is the largest ever. $124 trillion is expected to change hands; 50% of that is leaving from the wealthiest 2% of households. This transfer is creating family-money kids with an unprecedented amount of wealth. And family money is never more expected, than in housing. Parents worry about where their child lives: is it clean? Safe? A sound investment? Good for raising children? Doorman? Gym? A nice kitchen for Thanksgiving? These parents won’t take no for an answer — they’re going to help with the purchase of, or more interestingly, the rental of a home. And they’re doing so in spades.

Chayce Horton, a senior analyst at Cerulli Associates, said, “When people ask who can afford this rent the answer is, sometimes, people with parents who have money.” One broker says that he is constantly meeting parents in Connecticut, Long Island, or the Hamptons. These parents tell themselves, it’s an investment and we can use it as a pied-a-terre in the future. It is no surprise that parental support is more common than ever before; baby boomers hold more than half of the nation’s wealth. Only about one in three Americans under the age of 43 can financially support themselves, without the help of their parents. Nearly half of US parents support their adult children financially.

Co-op buildings complicate Bank of Mom and Dad purchases. A look at a few of the co-op buildings in Brooklyn Heights shows that they do not like it when Mom and Dad buy an apartment for their kiddo. In fact, at buildings like these it’s strictly banned.

Now, condos aren’t going to cause the same roadblock, but in some neighborhoods like Brooklyn Heights, Carroll Gardens, Fort Greene, and Park Slope (just to name those in Brooklyn), it can be tough to find a condo that meets all of Mom’s and Dad’s requirements.

So Gen Zers who know that Mom and Dad will make sure they are comfortable skip the part where they awkwardly ask for a home, and just ask Mom and Dad to pay rent. The wealthiest, most privileged Americans are renting very nice apartments, and not buying them. Naturally, we can expect the “merely well-off” Gen Zers to follow this trend. If they do it, then I can too. But that’s not the only reason.

Let’s consider a tech engineer moving to New York City, and let’s also consider their 1990s counterpart, a New York City bond trader. So we have an Anthropic engineer who has moved to NYC to work at the NYC Anthropic Office, who’s making about $350,000. Now, a bond trader in the 1990s, adjusted for inflation, is probably making about $200,000/year. Let’s call our Anthropic engineer Andy and our bond trader Bill.

Bill works on Wall Street and he needs to be in the office by 8:30 AM every morning. For a very nice one-bedroom apartment in Lower Manhattan, Bill pays $1,000 a month or $12,000 a year — 6% of his annual pre-tax salary. His other option is to buy something like a $350,000 home in Westchester or Long Island — a forty-minute drive in the morning costing him a little under two years of salary (pre-tax). Statistics indicates that by age 26, he’s likely getting married — only year three or four on the job. Now, he’s 26 or 27 with kids in the works, and he’s going to want a home. So he buys one.

Andy, on the other hand, moved to NYC after completing a CS degree at Stanford, and he looks at apartments in Midtown, near his office. It looks like it will be about $5,000 a month or $60,000 a year. That’s about 17% of Andy’s annual income. He get’s paid more, and he’s still paying more relative to his income — that’s because rent is too god damn expensive. Still, Andy can make it happen, with plenty of room to spare. His other option is a home in Westchester, like Bill’s. Let’s say that will cost, conservatively, $1.5 - 2 million. That’s four to six years of annual salary. Now, the current median marriage age for men is 30.8. So Andy has got about eight years of bachelorhood, and presumably renting, before even needing a reason to go out to the ‘burbs.

But what else is different between Bill and Andy, psychologically? Bill has been raised in a world where home-buying was the ultimate accomplishment. Bill knows, because his parents taught him, that when they bought their home in Westchester thirty years ago, it’s returned about 8.6% a year — just a little bit less than the stock market returned. And as a bond trader, Bill knows that diversification is key, and after all, owning a home is the American dream. No one at the country club rents an apartment.

Andy, though, has come up in a world of minimalism. He’s been steeped in essays like Paul Graham’s essay Stuff, renouncing worldly possessions for the sake of themselves. Andy also knows that when Bill bought his house for $350,000 in 1990 in Westchester, the same one Andy was considering buying, he only made 4.4% a year. The stock market returned 11% over the same time frame. Also, he has no fear that his peers at the modern-day country club (let us call it Life Time, the gym that costs $350/month) are going to judge him for renting, because many of them do too. In fact, even the wealthiest ones, with the most family money, are still renting. So why wouldn’t Andy continue to rent forever?

Now comes the economic reality that was too boring to lead with — high interest rates and low housing stock are also a factor here. But these more abstract and cultural influences are going to be more challenging to kick; just lowering rates will not immediately cause a spike in home buying. Additionally, they seem to be causes that neither investors nor regulators can really change. We only watch as the process of market sentiment runs, and make our best bet on what the outcome will be by studying human nature. More on where I see things headed at the end.

Staying mobile is also a factor for all three demographics we’ve outlined. They want to be ready to move to a new job, support a family member, travel for months and work remotely, or pursue a long-lost lover on the other side of the world, whenever they so please. The rich will pay a premium for this luxury. I read this as a form of Veblen’s Theory of the Leisure Class: they say to themselves, and the world, “financial orthodoxy and simple arithmetic be damned, I want to pack my bags and leave whenever I’d like!”

There are three primary objections people might have to this piece: (1) Gen Z does want to buy a home and they say so in polls all the time. It’s just a matter of affording it. (2) Rich young people have always rented in New York. (3) Some of the family money is actually going towards down payments on homes. I’m sure there’s (n) possible disagreements to be held here, so please reply to this email with any you can think of.

My reply to (1) that Gen Z wants to buy homes, they just can’t afford it.

Yes — this is what some polling indicates. But, when I see polling I see people answering questions on the phone. Where I see real data is from the people who are Gen Z and can afford a home and choose not to purchase one anyway. Further, the Gen Zers who want to buy a home but structurally can’t afford it might be interesting in the sociological sense, but aren’t much of a signal for an investor. Wanting isn’t demand; investors get paid on transactions.

My reply to (2) that rich young people have always rented in New York.

Yes — they have, but “young people” is getting older every year. In the past, you were expected to have a family and move out to the suburbs by your late 20s. Now, if you do so at that age, you’re way ahead of everyone else. And this means a lot of people are hitting their peak wealth years, when accounting for inheritance in The Great Wealth Transfer, far before they are ready or even interested in buying a home. That leaves us with the interesting question — will they eventually buy a home when they settle down, even if later in life, in their mid or late 30s?

My reply to (3) that some of the family money is going towards down payments.

Sure it is, and it always has, but data shows that more and more is going towards renting than ever before.

So as investors and operators, what is the play?

The winners are clear: luxury landlords and amenity towers. Losers are condo developers looking to sell into first-time home buyers, especially those purchasing on the higher end, and co-op buildings that don’t allow parents to buy for their kids.

My take: this is transitory, but transitory can sometimes feel permanent or structural to companies that are over-levered and not prepared to weather a longer and stronger storm than they might have expected. Put another way, sometimes an over-levered luxury condo developer in New York or Westchester can’t survive even a fleeting peril. I expect that home-buying will become necessary and normal again in the near future — probably less than a decade. I also expect that many folks will buy homes when they eventually start their families, even if that is in their thirties and not in their twenties.

Some original data I can leave you with:

According to polls we ran among Gen Zers, 72% prefer to buy not rent if money was not a factor. Among the reasons for choosing buying over renting are (direct quotes from open answer field on a survey):

This poll surveyed a selection of 150 Gen Zers; these survey participants were all located in the United States.

“Keeping something rather than using it momentarily, more freedom to customize it to my liking.”

“I guess our psychological fantasy of owning assets over renting them.”

“The fact of feeling that I own something!”

“More authority”

“No rules on pets, no waiting for fixing things, no homeowner inspections”

'“You can make a profit on it,”

Now, before we wrap up this article, we’d love it if you could click “forward” in your email inbox on this, and send it to the following: a person you know who works in real estate, a young person you know in the housing market, or anyone else you know that might be interested. Just one forward! That makes this work possible. Please help us out.

Note about PTT Pro:

We want to go deeper on this. We’d love to do interviews with owners and renters in areas like Brooklyn Heights, get some original survey data, speak with experts and dive into data archives, and explore exact buildings and blocks that we find promising and share why. If you think this would be of use, please purchase PTT Pro access below, and send us an email saying you did so. Then, we’ll reply within 24 hours to come up with the best way for us to approach this question in a follow-up article.

PTT Pro also includes a Friday Pro Memo, with weekly write-ups of stocks in our Gen Z Coverage Universe prepared by our lead analyst and full transcripts and access to our interviews with notable guests. Emile and Jasper reply to PTT Pro Members within 24 hours at all times, for all questions.

Thanks for reading, and as always, stay curious folks!

—J&E

In partnership with

It's time to set up your holiday streaming campaign

Are you ready to reach holiday shoppers on CTV? For many streamers, the season is already underway.

Last year, according to Roku internal data, holiday content searches on Roku saw an 86% increase during October. And in November, those searches rise an average of 39% weekly. This surging holiday spirit is mirrored by consumer activity, as about half of Roku streamers shopped Black Friday and Cyber Monday deals in 2025.

Meeting those shoppers is easier than you might think. Begin with the seasonal outcome you hope to drive: awareness, online sales, leads, store visits, or another measurable goal. From there, define your audience, upload your creative, set the budget and campaign dates, and establish measurement before launching. You can even create a shoppable ad unit that lets streamers buy with a click of their remote.

Our holiday playbook offers a month-by-month guide to reaching shoppers during this all-important time of year.

First-time spenders get a $5,000 match on the first $5,000 spent with code BEEHIIV5K. Terms apply.

Subscribe to keep reading

This content is free, but you must be subscribed to Passing the Torch Newsletter to continue reading.

Already a subscriber?Sign in.Not now