dummy hum blog: Adam Smith and Karl Marx

Yours truly, the authors of this newsletter, Jasper and Emile, are of differing minds, politically. One (we will not name names; if you know us, you’ll probably be able to do the math) is a fierce advocate for free markets, minimal government, and as little taxation as justly possible. The other believes that oftentimes markets get things wrong, and that currently there are whole cohorts of individuals being “ripped off” and who deserve some form of recognition, whether it be through redistribution of wealth, or the abolishment of certain parts of our capital system, or the government seizure of certain aspects of industry. These two, J&E, find a way to make every disagreement about this fundamental difference.

If they’re arguing about which train is better to take…they’re going to end up screaming about economic distribution. If they’re arguing about whether Emile wore the same pants three days in a row (he did), they’re going to end up arguing about the need for a wealth tax. Anyone who’s been around them knows this.

The question then begs itself: How do these two people, of near opposite mind, manage to run a media business and write incredibly frequent cultural, economic, political, and social commentary together? Although some of our work may be fractured, and some articles may lean one direction more than others, we aim to keep a uniform “house-view” on most big questions. We think we’ve done a pretty good job.

This is all a very long wind up to what I’m about to say; there is one issue always J&E agree on, and many others from different ends of different parties agree on too: AI. More specifically, J&E agree that AI should come second to human interest, and that it exists as a tool to serve humans ends. It is a means to an end. Humans are not means to an end. That’s a fundamental difference that must be acknowledged.

Additionally, J&E both passionately agree that AI writing and art, especially in the box-office and at the publishing houses (alas, we cannot really advocate for less AI on Substack, it’s just too large of a trash mountain to scale), has no place. Humans write and humans make art. Correction: smart humans write and smart humans make art. I’m not sure what word I’d use for the humans who decide that AI ought to be winning it’s own short story competition (and to the competition board who decided to give the award anyway).

Between J&E, one is a genuine populist and one is a borderline elitist (although he’d prefer the term meritocratist). Yet they both agree on one thing: AI needs to take a breather.

It doesn’t need to be banned or neutered in some massive ceremonial beheading. We just need to as a society step back and take a breath. See below an article we’ve written essentially claiming that we’re going to get really fed up with AI, regardless:

So we’re kind of making a call and making a plea at the same time. Read human books. Go out to eat. Grab a handful of grass and throw it at somebody. These are the things that “Members of Technical Staff” can never take away from us.

And we aren’t some kind of Luddite, nor do we fail to believe in progress. Quite the opposite. Innovation is terrific and necessary. But innovation like this one, innovation that makes it impossible to innovate or compete ever again, because humans will be just a tiny speck in the intellectual ecosystem—that sounds like hell. Humans work hard, they learn and read, and they become great. Americans work hard, learn and read, and become great.

Let’s make sure we don’t allow AI to slip us a Xanax and make us relax on the beach, wearing T-Shirts that say, “I love abundance. It’s just so boring.”

Thanks for reading & as always, stay curious folks!

—J&E

Please consider a paid subscription, if you enjoy our content. This is a free article because we like to keep things open to the entire audience. We are oftentimes finding our revenue punished by readers when we write about AI…we are also exposing ourselves to financial pain, via the lack of AI sponsorship revenue. If you find it important for people like us to speak out about various issues with AI, please consider signing up for a paid subscription so we can continue to do this work.