The Bureau of Labor Statistics just dropped a number that should make every parent, educator, and policymaker sit up: 9.7% unemployment for bachelor’s degree holders ages 20-24.That’s up from 6.8% a year ago. For context, that’s the kind of number we saw during the financial crisis.
But unemployment is only half the story. The New York Fed reports that 41% of recent college graduates are underemployed — meaning they’re working jobs that don’t require their degree. Baristas with biology degrees. Uber drivers with MBAs. The American dream, except, it’s not working at all.
This is the first generation in modern American history projected to be worse off than their parents. And the data is finally catching up to what young people have been saying for years (and everyone just called it “complaining”).
The Social Contract Is Broken
Here’s the deal that was sold to an entire generation: Work hard. Go to college. Get a good job. Buy a house. Build wealth slowly over 40 years. Retire.
Every single part of that equation has collapsed.
The job market? The Cleveland Fed found that college graduates are now spending more time unemployed than job seekers with only a high school diploma. Read that again. The “advantage” of a four-year degree — at least in terms of finding work quickly — has functionally disappeared.
Housing? The median home price hit $435,300 in June 2025, a record high. The median age for first-time homebuyers is now 40 years old — the highest since the National Association of Realtors started tracking in 1981. First-time buyers are now just 21% of all purchases, a historic low.
We asked high schoolers and recent college grads what this feels like on the ground. Here’s what they told us:
“It’s like there are literally no options.”
“There was nowhere to go and now everyone gets rich off AI while we can’t get a job.”
“I have three friends out of everyone I know who could afford an apartment after college — and all three are being covered by their parents. And I went to NYU Stern.”
That last one is the kicker. We’re not talking about people who made bad choices. We’re talking about people who did everything right — elite school, business degree, good grades — and still can’t afford to live independently.
Something’s Not Adding Up
Let’s do some quick arithmetic.
The average college graduate enters the workforce with student debt and competes for entry-level jobs that increasingly demand 3-5 years of experience. The median home now costs $435K. At current mortgage rates (~6.8%), a 20% down payment and a 30-year mortgage means a $2,273 monthly payment — before property taxes, before insurance, before maintenance.
To afford that comfortably (using the 28% rule), you’d need a household income of roughly $97,000.
The median starting salary for a college graduate? About $60,000.
So even if you land a job — which, reminder, 41% of grads don’t land a degree-appropriate job — you still can’t afford the house your parents bought at 27.
Also, try and forget about the fact that basically any jobs paying enough to afford the Average American Home are in the cities where that home price is anywhere from 4x-10x on average.
The St. Louis Fed put it bluntly: young college graduates are experiencing unemployment rates of 4.59% in 2025, compared to 3.25% in 2019. That 1.34 percentage point increase is more than double the increase for non-college-educated workers in the same age range.
The college premium — the idea that a degree guarantees better outcomes — isn’t gone, but it’s eroding. Fast.
When the Safe Path Disappears, People Gamble
Here’s what happens when you tell an entire generation that the rules don’t apply to them anymore: they stop playing by the rules.
42% of Gen Z investors now own cryptocurrency — nearly four times the 11% who have a retirement account. Gen Z is more likely than any other generation to invest in meme stocks, crypto, and leveraged ETFs. CNBC calls it “financial nihilism” — and honestly, it’s hard to argue with the logic.
If index funds return 10% annually but inflation eats half of that, and houses appreciate faster than you can save, and your degree doesn’t guarantee a job anyway — why wouldn’t you YOLO into Dogecoin?
The traditional path to wealth (slow, steady, 401k contributions over decades) assumes a baseline stability that no longer exists for young people. When the safe path feels impossible, speculation starts to look rational. It’s not that Gen Z is reckless. It’s that the game changed and nobody told them until they were already playing.
Three out of every ten Gen Zers have given up on buying a home altogether, according to a U.S. Bank survey. Not “delayed.” Given up.
What’s Actually Happening
This isn’t a cyclical downturn. This is structural.
The Cleveland Fed researchers didn’t mince words: “A long period of relatively easier job-finding prospects for college grads has ended.” They traced this back not to AI (though that’s accelerating things) but to a decades-long shift from “college-biased to education-neutral growth in labor demand.”
Translation: the economy used to reward degrees. Now it’s indifferent to them.
Meanwhile, the Burning Glass Institute found that 52% of graduates are underemployed one year after graduation — and 44% are still underemployed ten years later For most of those who start behind, it’s a permanent detour.
The institutions are starting to notice. Policymakers are starting to notice. The question is whether anyone will actually do something about it — or whether we’ll just keep telling 18-year-olds to take on six figures of debt for a credential that increasingly doesn’t pay off.
The Takeaway
This isn’t a hot take. This is Federal Reserve data, Bureau of Labor Statistics data, and the lived experience of an entire generation.
The system that worked for your parents — that promised stability in exchange for compliance — doesn’t work anymore. And young people aren’t lazy or entitled for noticing. They’re just reading the room.
The question for everyone else is: what are we going to do about it?
Tune into our podcast where we talked about this in more depth here:
Sources: Bureau of Labor Statistics, Federal Reserve Bank of New York, Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis, Federal Reserve Bank of Cleveland, National Association of Realtors, Burning Glass Institute, U.S. Bank, CNBC
—J&E